EA Response求助:负极材料测试数据用的是充电比容量吗?本人最近投了EA,审稿意见回来,编辑给了大修,三个审稿人,l两个的意见还比较中肯,不过其中第一个审稿人应该是拒稿,不仅说没有新意而且提个几个建议很奇怪,说让在循环性能和倍率性能图中充电比容量替代放电比容量....有点不解,因为文献上大多用的放电比容量加库伦效率就行了。Reviewer #1: The work in this manuscript does not seem to contain a new and original contribution, not only in materials synthesizing, but also in result discussion. So, it is improper to publish in Electerochimica Acta.In addition, for anode, the researcher concern more about its charge capacity, but not its discharge capacity, because it was used as positive electrode in simulated battery.. So, there are several points that should be correct in this manuscript:(1)? ?In t Fig.6, Fig.7,??the??caption of Y-axis of should be changed for charge capacity;(2)??In highlights of page 26, line5 "The discharge capacity can still be retained??mAh g-1 in the 100th cycle at 100 mA g-1", in this statement, discharge capacity should be changed to charge capacity.怎么回复这个审稿人啊,求高人帮忙.....查看更多4个回答 . 7人已关注